The Mistress (2023) movie poster

The Mistress

2023 ·1h 42m · ★ 4.6 (47)

Newlyweds Parker and Madeline move into their dream home. As they settle in, they discover a box of old love letters written to the original owner. And as the couple digs into the increasingly obsessive correspondence, a mysterious woman arrives with a horrifying secret that threatens their lives.

Why it matters

A haunted-house slow burn where the past doesn’t stay in the box—and newlywed bliss curdles into intimate, old-fashioned dread.

  • The love letters turn a familiar dream-home setup into a mystery built on obsession, secrets, and the uneasy intimacy of reading someone else’s private life.
  • Its domestic setting keeps the threat close: this is less haunted-house spectacle than a marriage under pressure.
  • Best suited to viewers who like patient supernatural suspense and romantic unease over a steady barrage of scares.
  • The premise has classic Gothic bones, though its slow-burn approach may test viewers looking for a more relentless payoff.

Horror DNA

⚠ Limited data — scores are approximate
Gore not enough information
Slow Burn
36
Psychological
50
Supernatural not enough information
Creature
24
Disturbing not enough information
Fun Factor not enough information
Cerebral not enough information
Survival not enough information

Content Warnings

Sexual Violence not confirmedChild in Danger not confirmedTaboo Content not confirmedBody Horror not confirmedCannibalism not confirmedEye Trauma not confirmedPregnancy Horror not confirmedDehumanization not confirmedTorture not confirmedAnimal Harm not confirmedMedical Gore not confirmed

Phobia triggers

Spiders not confirmedClowns not confirmedDolls Puppets not confirmedMannequins not confirmedDentistry not confirmedDeep Water not confirmedNeedles not confirmedHeights not confirmedSnakes not confirmedVomit not confirmedFlashing Lights not confirmedTight Spaces not confirmedEyes not confirmedPregnancy Birth not confirmedTeeth not confirmedInsects not confirmedDogs not confirmedReligious Imagery not confirmedMirrors not confirmedMedical Procedures not confirmed

Pairs Well With