An American Crime (2007) movie poster

An American Crime

2007 ·1h 37m · ★ 7.3 (805)

The true story of suburban housewife Gertrude Baniszewski, who kept a teenage girl locked in the basement of her Indiana home during the 1960s.

Why it matters

A grim dive into the psychology of suburban evil, exploring how cruelty festers behind closed doors.

  • Catherine Keener’s chilling, nuanced turn as Gertrude anchors the film in unsettling realism.
  • Focuses less on spectacle, more on the corrosive mindset of abusers—an uncomfortable but vital perspective.
  • A slow burn that demands patience; its quiet tension is a study in simmering menace rather than overt horror.
  • Best suited for fans of true crime horrors interested in character-driven narratives over gore or shock.

Horror DNA

Gore
28
Slow Burn
33
Psychological
34
Supernatural
21
Creature
0
Disturbing
90
Fun Factor
17
Cerebral
66
Survival
32

Setting

Church

Content Warnings

Sexual ViolenceChild in DangerTaboo ContentDehumanizationTorture

Phobia triggers

Needles Tight Spaces not confirmed

TMDB Keywords

1960sbased on true storybasementcarnivalchild abusedysfunctional familyfemale child abuserjumping on a bedmistreatmentmurderrapesingle motherteenage girltorturetrue crimewatching tv

Pairs Well With