I Still Know What You Did Last Summer (1998) movie poster

I Still Know What You Did Last Summer

1998 ·1h 40m · ★ 5.3 (1,838)

Ever since killing the Fisherman one year ago, Julie James is still haunted by images of him after her. When her best friend Karla wins free tickets to the Bahamas, Julie finds this a perfect opportunity to finally relax. But someone is waiting for her. Someone who she thought was dead. Someone who is out again for revenge.

Why it matters

A glossy late-’90s slasher sequel that doubles down on body count but struggles to capture the original’s grounded suspense.

  • More kills and tropical locales but less tension—shifts from eerie coastal town to sun-soaked Bahamas without boosting stakes.
  • Jennifer Love Hewitt remains the franchise’s anchor, though the new supporting cast fails to leave a mark.
  • For fans who crave ’90s slasher nostalgia and don’t mind a sequel that tips into formulaic territory.
  • Highlights the challenge of sequels trying to recapture lightning without reinventing the wheel—useful case study in franchise fatigue.

Horror DNA

Gore
47
Slow Burn
39
Psychological
75
Supernatural
27
Creature
3
Disturbing
47
Fun Factor
60
Cerebral
33
Survival
100
RevengeSlasher

Setting

Island

Content Warnings

Torture Eye Trauma not confirmedDehumanization not confirmedAnimal Harm not confirmed

Phobia triggers

MannequinsTight SpacesMirrors Spiders not confirmedClowns not confirmedDolls Puppets not confirmedDeep Water not confirmedNeedles not confirmedHeights not confirmedSnakes not confirmedVomit not confirmedFlashing Lights not confirmedEyes not confirmedInsects not confirmedDogs not confirmedReligious Imagery not confirmed

TMDB Keywords

bahamascollegecompetitionfishermanhookkillerknifemarijuanamurderradioresortridiculousstormvacation

Pairs Well With