I've Been Waiting for You (1998) movie poster

I've Been Waiting for You

1998 ·1h 30m · ★ 4.9 (41)

When a New England high schooler is mysteriously murdered, the town blames Sarah, the new girl who recently moved into a purportedly haunted house and who they believe to be the reincarnation of a witch who was burned at the stake 300 years ago.

Why it matters

A slow-burning witchcraft mystery that fuses teen drama with New England folklore, anchoring supernatural dread in small-town paranoia.

  • Anchored by a moody, atmospheric setting that channels classic folk horror vibes without the usual rural isolation—this is suburbia with a sinister past.
  • Plays on the enduring witch trial mythos, tapping into generational guilt and scapegoating as a cultural anxiety that still resonates today.
  • Delivers a quietly unsettling mood more than jump scares—this one’s for fans of psychological tension over gore.
  • While pacing lags and the mystery unravels predictably, the film’s earnestness and period touches give it a cult appeal for folk horror completists.
3 horror films in catalog

Horror DNA

Gore
0
Slow Burn
35
Psychological
43
Supernatural
60
Creature
0
Disturbing
50
Fun Factor
58
Cerebral
56
Survival
38
Revenge

Content Warnings

Child in DangerDehumanization

Phobia triggers

Flashing Lights not confirmed

TMDB Keywords

teen angstwitch

Pairs Well With