We All Scream for Ice Cream (2007) movie poster

We All Scream for Ice Cream

2007 ·57m · ★ 5.0 (53)

Years ago, they pulled a disastrous childhood prank on the neighborhood ice cream delivery man that got him killed, but now as they've become adults with families of their own, the last thing anyone expected was for that man to come back in the form of a vengeful, bloodthirsty spirit.

Why it matters

A low-budget scream queen slasher that mixes suburban guilt with supernatural vengeance in a sticky-sweet package.

  • Practical gore effects lean into ‘00s DTV charm, delivering messy kills with old-school flair.
  • A haunted childhood prank fuels its creepy small-town atmosphere—think early Elm Street with a frosty twist.
  • Perfect for fans of nostalgic, under-the-radar horror who appreciate flawed but earnest genre entries.
  • Not a polished thriller, but its earnestness and cult potential make it a guilty pleasure for practical-effect enthusiasts.
4 horror films in catalog

Horror DNA

⚠ Limited data — scores are approximate
Gore
35
Slow Burn
16
Psychological
24
Supernatural
21
Creature
36
Disturbing
25
Fun Factor
60
Cerebral
17
Survival
44

Content Warnings

Child in Danger not confirmedBody Horror not confirmedEye Trauma not confirmedTorture not confirmedAnimal Harm not confirmedMedical Gore not confirmed

Phobia triggers

Clowns Vomit not confirmedFlashing Lights not confirmedTight Spaces not confirmedEyes not confirmedTeeth not confirmedDogs not confirmedMirrors not confirmedMedical Procedures not confirmed

Pairs Well With