I Am Not a Serial Killer (2016) movie poster

I Am Not a Serial Killer

2016 ·1h 44m · ★ 6.3 (562)

In a small Midwestern town, a troubled teen with homicidal tendencies must hunt down and destroy a supernatural killer while keeping his own inner demons at bay.

Why it matters

A psychologically sharp blend of supernatural horror and coming-of-age trauma that probes what lurks beneath the surface of a small-town mind.

  • Bill Skarsgård anchors the film with a chilling, nuanced turn as a teen wrestling homicidal impulses and monstrous threats alike.
  • Christopher Lloyd’s unexpected but pitch-perfect casting adds an eerie, darkly comic gravitas that elevates the familiar genre tropes.
  • The film’s Midwestern setting grounds the supernatural in a bleak, almost clinical atmosphere—less jump scare, more slow burn dread.
  • Fans of horror that doubles as character study and moral puzzle will find this a refreshing twist on serial killer and monster movie conventions.
2 horror films in catalog

Horror DNA

Gore
43
Slow Burn
33
Psychological
29
Supernatural
20
Creature
55
Disturbing
50
Fun Factor
72
Cerebral
37
Survival
25
Serial KillerStalkingSupernatural

Content Warnings

Child in DangerTaboo ContentBody HorrorMedical Gore

Phobia triggers

Flashing LightsMedical Procedures Needles not confirmed

TMDB Keywords

based on novel or bookchristmasembalminggoregpshalloweenhigh schoolholidaysmidwestminnesotamurderpsychopathsnowthanksgivingtracking devicetroubled teenwinter

Pairs Well With