Return of the Tooth Fairy (2020) movie poster

Return of the Tooth Fairy

2020 ·1h 31m · ★ 6.5 (856)

The Tooth Fairy is back. 15 years after the events of the first movie, Corey, now grown up but mentally scarred has gone to a class reunion. However, the Tooth Fairy is back, and this time - You better have flossed properly.

Why it matters

A low-budget slasher with a dental twist that leans into campy kills and nostalgic ‘00s horror vibes.

  • Practical effects take a backseat, but the Tooth Fairy’s grotesque design still delivers some cringe-worthy moments.
  • Perfect for fans of late-90s/early-2000s creature features who appreciate a throwback grindhouse feel.
  • The reunion setting taps into familiar slasher tropes — think “Final Destination” meets “Leprechaun” with a floss obsession.
  • Not for those seeking subtlety or high production values, but a guilty pleasure for lovers of goofy, offbeat killers.
5 horror films in catalog

Horror DNA

⚠ Limited data — scores are approximate
Gore not enough information
Slow Burn not enough information
Psychological
50
Supernatural not enough information
Creature
37
Disturbing not enough information
Fun Factor not enough information
Cerebral not enough information
Survival not enough information

Content Warnings

Sexual Violence not confirmedChild in Danger not confirmedTaboo Content not confirmedBody Horror not confirmedCannibalism not confirmedEye Trauma not confirmedPregnancy Horror not confirmedDehumanization not confirmedTorture not confirmedAnimal Harm not confirmedMedical Gore not confirmed

Phobia triggers

DentistryTeeth Spiders not confirmedClowns not confirmedDolls Puppets not confirmedMannequins not confirmedDeep Water not confirmedNeedles not confirmedHeights not confirmedSnakes not confirmedVomit not confirmedFlashing Lights not confirmedTight Spaces not confirmedEyes not confirmedPregnancy Birth not confirmedInsects not confirmedDogs not confirmedReligious Imagery not confirmedMirrors not confirmedMedical Procedures not confirmed

Pairs Well With